local seo
There’s no license to practice SEO. No certification board. No barrier to entry. Which means the person charging $5,000 a month and the person charging $500 might have identical credentials — none.
That puts the entire burden of evaluation on you. Here’s how to handle it.
Before you look at a single consultant, write down your business goal. Not “I need SEO.” The actual outcome you’re after.
Trying to show up when someone searches “roofing contractor Lexington”? That’s local SEO. Running an e-commerce site that needs to rank for product categories? That’s a different skill set. Recovering from a penalty or migration disaster? That’s technical remediation work.
The consultant who’s great at one of these might be terrible at the others. Know what you’re hiring for.
Core work includes keyword research, on-page optimization, technical audits, local search setup, and earning legitimate backlinks. They should also explain their strategy in plain language and report results you can actually understand.
Beyond the task list, look for these:
Specifics, not claims. Ask for examples with numbers. Not “I helped a client increase traffic” — actual before/after data. If they can’t show you proof, they probably don’t have it.
Clear explanations. Good consultants can tell you what they’re doing and why it matters. If someone hides behind jargon or refuses to explain their methodology, walk away.
Custom strategy. Your business isn’t identical to their last three clients. Be suspicious of anyone selling the same package to everyone without asking detailed questions about your situation first.
Local expertise if you need it. If you depend on local customers, make sure they know Google Business Profile optimization, citation management, and review strategy. These aren’t afterthoughts.
Referrals from people you trust. Ask other business owners in your area. First-hand recommendations beat any online review system.
LinkedIn search. Look for consultants in your region. Check their work history, client endorsements, and how they present themselves professionally.
Local directories. Google, Yelp, Chamber of Commerce listings. These surface consultants who are active in your market.
Search results themselves. Search “[your city] SEO consultant” and see who ranks locally. If they can’t get themselves visible, that tells you something.
Once you have a shortlist:
Ask about past projects. Specific ones. What was the challenge, what did they do, what changed? Vague answers mean they’re either hiding something or they don’t have real experience.
Understand reporting. How often will you hear from them? What metrics will they track? How will they present progress? If they can’t answer this clearly, you’ll be frustrated three months in.
Get pricing upfront. Hourly, monthly retainer, project-based — whatever it is, clarify it before you start. No surprises.
Talk to references. Not testimonials on their website. Actual people you can call or email independently.
Start small if possible. A trial project or short-term engagement lets you evaluate their work before committing long-term.
Expect $75–$300 per hour for consulting work, or $1,000–$5,000+ per month for ongoing retainers, depending on scope and your market.
Anyone charging dramatically less is either inexperienced, offshoring the work without telling you, or cutting corners you’ll pay for later.
SEO results usually show up in three to six months. Sometimes longer. It’s not fast, and anyone promising guaranteed rankings in weeks is lying to you.
The honest ones set realistic expectations upfront and explain what affects timing — your market, competition, site history, budget.
SEO isn’t a project you finish. It’s ongoing work. The best consultant relationships are long-term partnerships where they understand your business deeply and adjust strategy as things change.
Here’s something we’ve learned that applies to SEO tools and automation: when you’re running multiple systems — rank trackers, reporting tools, automated audits, backlink monitors, content calendars — you need an inventory of what’s scheduling what.
We’ve seen setups where the same SEO task was running in three different places because nobody documented the automation as it grew. Or where a critical weekly report stopped running because it was tied to a tool nobody remembered they were still paying for.
If your consultant is setting up automation (and they should be), make sure they document where everything runs and how to access it. Otherwise you inherit a system you can’t maintain when they leave.
You’re hiring someone with no formal credentials to do work you probably can’t evaluate directly. That’s uncomfortable.
The way through it: ask specific questions, demand proof, start small, and trust your instincts about whether someone is being straight with you.
The good ones exist. They’re just mixed in with a lot of noise.
Let's have a real conversation about what's getting in the way — and how we fix it.
Schedule a call →