local seo
Here’s what we’ve learned running audits for years: they only work when they reveal gaps the client can’t fill themselves.
If your prospect already has an in-house SEO team, your audit becomes a competitor analysis exercise. They’ll use it to validate what they already know or argue with your methodology. Conversion drops to near-zero.
The audit that converts shows a business owner something broken they didn’t know existed — and can’t fix without help.
Technical audit — The backend infrastructure: site speed, crawlability, indexing status, mobile responsiveness, SSL configuration, URL structure, redirect chains. These problems are invisible to users but kill you in search engines.
On-page audit — Content and HTML elements on each page: title tags, meta descriptions, header hierarchy, keyword targeting, internal linking structure, content depth.
Off-page audit — Your backlink profile: who links to you, whether those links help or hurt, and what your competitors have that you don’t.
Content audit — The full content library: thin pages, outdated information, keyword cannibalization, consolidation opportunities.
A real audit covers all four. Anything less is incomplete.
Initial consultation — Understanding business goals, target audience, current pain points. The audit gets scoped to what matters for this specific situation, not a generic checklist.
Site overview — Reviewing architecture, content volume, existing traffic data from Analytics and Search Console.
Crawl and indexing analysis — Running a full site crawl to identify technical issues: broken links, crawl errors, duplicate content, pages that aren’t indexed.
Technical evaluation — Page speed testing, mobile usability, HTTPS status, structured data implementation, Core Web Vitals.
On-page review — Page-by-page optimization check: proper keyword targeting, tag structure, whether pages are competing against each other for the same terms.
Off-page analysis — Backlink profile review. Finding high-value links, identifying toxic links to disavow, spotting competitor link gaps.
Competitor benchmarking — Where you stand relative to businesses competing for the same search traffic.
Recommendations report — Prioritized findings with specific next steps, organized by impact and implementation difficulty.
A quality audit delivers:
If you get a data dump without recommendations, push back. The value isn’t finding problems — it’s knowing what to do about them.
We’ve learned this the hard way: document exactly what the audit owns and what it doesn’t. When multiple systems are running (Analytics, Search Console, third-party tools), maintain a single source of truth. Otherwise you end up with orphaned recommendations and duplicate work.
Most audits surface some combination of:
That last one matters more than people think. If someone on your team has to manually prep data or fix something before your site works properly, that’s technical debt with a name. It needs to either get fully automated or explicitly documented so it doesn’t become a silent bottleneck.
An audit without follow-through is wasted money.
Work through prioritized recommendations systematically. Start with high-impact technical issues blocking search engines from properly accessing your site.
Schedule a follow-up assessment six months after implementation to measure improvement and catch new issues. SEO isn’t a one-time fix. Audits should happen at least annually, or any time you make major site changes.
One more thing we’ve learned: add inline documentation as you go. When you’re mapping data or making optimization decisions, document your assumptions — especially around time periods, categorization logic, or display rules. It prevents expensive ambiguity later when someone makes wrong assumptions about what a field means.
Look for proven experience with documented results. Ask what tools they use and how they prioritize findings.
Avoid anyone guaranteeing specific ranking outcomes from an audit. No one can promise that. What they can promise is a clear picture of your current state and a roadmap to improve it.
The best audits reveal what you’re leaving on the table — and give you a plan to go get it.
Let's have a real conversation about what's getting in the way — and how we fix it.
Schedule a call →