paid ads
Before you talk to anyone, answer these internally:
What’s the specific problem? “Better marketing” isn’t a problem. “We’re generating 20 leads monthly and need 50” is a problem. “Our Google Ads cost per acquisition is killing us” is a problem. Specificity attracts better agencies and produces better proposals.
Who is our customer? The more precisely you can describe your target audience — demographics, behaviors, pain points, purchase triggers — the better an agency can design strategy to reach them.
What does success look like at 6 and 12 months? Revenue targets, lead volume, customer acquisition cost, brand awareness metrics. Define these before you shop.
What’s our budget? Know your number. Budget determines what’s realistic and screens for agencies that work at your scale.
Not all agencies are generalists. Some specialize in specific channels (paid search, social ads, SEO). Some specialize in industries (healthcare, legal, e-commerce). Relevant specialization is valuable.
Build a list of 5–8 agencies. You’ll narrow from there. Google search with your industry, check Clutch and G2 for verified reviews, look at LinkedIn activity, ask peers in non-competing businesses.
Here’s where most businesses get burned: they accept marketing about marketing instead of verifying actual operational capability.
Ask for live system access demonstrations. If an agency claims to manage Google Ads, Meta campaigns, or analytics platforms, ask them to show you real-time access during your evaluation. Not screenshots. Not case studies. Actual dashboards with live data flow.
We’ve learned this the hard way: agencies that can’t demonstrate technical integration points or explain how data moves through their systems often don’t have operational control. They’re reselling someone else’s work or they’re winging it.
Understand where data actually lives. There’s a difference between systems of record and reporting layers. Good agencies keep sensitive operational details in source systems and surface appropriate summaries. If everything lives in slide decks or monthly PDFs, you’re getting theater.
Map sensitivity boundaries explicitly. Before engagement, document what data is confidential, what’s internal-only, what can be public. Agencies should have clear protocols for each tier and explain their access controls and data handling per category.
If they can’t articulate this clearly, they haven’t thought it through.
Check their own infrastructure. How does their website rank? How’s their social presence? An SEO agency that doesn’t rank for its own keywords should raise questions.
Ask about their technical stack. For high-volume work — publishing, monitoring, campaign management — look for automation with human oversight on strategy. Pure manual processes don’t scale. Pure automation lacks judgment. The split should be explicit and documented.
We’ve seen too many agencies running outdated tooling or unable to explain their deployment process. That technical debt becomes yours when things break.
Questions worth asking:
Pay attention to whether they ask good questions about your business. Agencies that propose solutions before understanding your situation are selling packages, not strategy.
Response time matters. If they’re slow to respond to a potential client, they’ll be slower when you’re paying.
Client references. Request two or three in similar industries or business sizes. Call them. Ask specifically about communication, reporting, and whether results met expectations.
Reviews beyond their website. Check Google reviews, Clutch, LinkedIn. Look for patterns in positive and negative feedback.
Monthly retainer — Fixed fee for ongoing services. Most common. Good for consistent, long-term work.
Project-based — Fixed price for defined deliverables. Good for one-time work: audits, site launches, campaign setup.
Performance-based — You pay based on results. Sounds appealing but requires careful contract review. Definitions of “results” matter enormously.
Understand exactly what’s included. Agencies vague about deliverables are vague about value.
Evaluate on:
Trust your judgment on fit. You’ll work closely with this team. Cultural alignment and communication style matter.
Timeline reality: expect 3–6 months before significant results from most digital marketing efforts. Agencies promising faster transformations without very specific reasoning are overselling.
Let's have a real conversation about what's getting in the way — and how we fix it.
Schedule a call →