paid ads
Choosing a digital marketing partner is a significant business decision. The wrong choice costs you money and months of lost momentum. The right choice can compound your growth for years. Most businesses pick agencies based on the wrong criteria.
Here’s how to do it right.
Before talking to any agency, answer these questions internally:
What’s the specific problem? “Better marketing” isn’t a problem. “We’re generating 20 leads per month and need 50” is a problem. “Our cost per acquisition from Google Ads is too high” is a problem. Specificity attracts better agencies and produces better proposals.
Who is our customer? The more precisely you can describe your target audience — demographics, behaviors, pain points, purchase triggers — the better an agency can design a strategy to reach them.
What does success look like at 6 months and 12 months? Revenue targets, lead volume, customer acquisition cost, brand awareness metrics. Define these before you shop.
What’s our budget? Know your number before you start conversations. Budget determines what’s realistic and screens for agencies that work at your scale.
Not all agencies are generalists. Some specialize in specific channels (paid search, social ads, SEO). Some specialize in specific industries (healthcare, legal, e-commerce). Relevant specialization is valuable.
Where to look:
Build a list of 5–8 agencies to evaluate. You’ll narrow from there.
Portfolio and case studies — Ask for examples from clients in your industry or with similar goals. Specific numbers matter: “increased organic traffic by 40%” is better than “improved online presence.” Ask to speak with the client referenced.
Certifications — Google Ads certification, HubSpot certification, Meta Business Partner status — these indicate the agency invests in current training. They’re not sufficient criteria on their own, but they’re a data point.
Service range — Does the agency offer the specific services you need? Do they have genuine depth in those services or is it a checkbox on their capabilities list?
Their own marketing — How does their website rank? How’s their social presence? An SEO agency that doesn’t rank for its own keywords should raise questions.
Client reviews — Look beyond the testimonials on their website. Check Google reviews, Clutch, and LinkedIn. Look for patterns in positive and negative feedback.
References — Request two or three client references in a similar industry or business size. Call them. Ask specifically about communication, reporting, and whether results met expectations.
Response time in your evaluation process — If they’re slow to respond to a potential client, they’ll be slower when you’re a paying one.
Interview at least three agencies. Questions worth asking:
Pay attention to whether they ask good questions about your business. Agencies that propose solutions before understanding your situation thoroughly are selling packages, not strategy.
Monthly retainer — Fixed fee for ongoing services. Good for consistent, long-term work. Most common model.
Project-based — Fixed price for a defined deliverable. Good for one-time work: an audit, a site launch, a campaign setup.
Performance-based — You pay based on results (leads generated, revenue driven). Sounds appealing but requires careful contract review — definitions of “results” matter enormously.
Understand exactly what’s included in any pricing proposal. Agencies that are vague about deliverables are vague about value.
After interviews, evaluate on:
Trust your judgment on fit. You’ll be working closely with this team. Cultural alignment and communication style matter.
Timeline reality: expect 3–6 months before significant results from most digital marketing efforts. Agencies promising faster transformations without very specific reasoning are overselling.
Let's have a real conversation about what's getting in the way — and how we fix it.
Schedule a call →